Why comment?

Insecure Writers Support Group Badge

During April I read more blog posts than usual, mainly as part of the Blogging from A to Z Challenge. However, I didn’t comment on as many of them as I should have done, judging by some amazing people like the Ninja Captain. How does he do it?

I know that it is common courtesy to acknowledge the effort someone has made writing a post. So I tried to tweet most of them. But that’s another insecurity: how to thanks all my own re-tweeters like others do.

Anyway back to the comments. I made a few, even trying to stick to the letter of the day – expressing enthusiastic enchantment OR waxing weighty worded warnings.

Quality not quantity?

And when a post already has 96 comments, I hesitate to add another one aping others – unless I have a unique perspective that is worth sharing. But that’s unlikely.

Does my reluctance mean anything? Never that I disliked the post, even when some were long articles although erudite ones.

But I suspect making few comments reduces the traffic to my site. The figures support that fact – 96:3.

What do you think? Or is it a matter of “No Comment”?


NOTE: I won’t comment on any posts for a few days as I’m travelling = a better excuse than the gerbil chewed my thoughts. How about the monster maelstrom sucks?

Maybe sometimes, monster shark munches severely, meaning stressed mind spasms. Maelstrom swamps my serenity.


The first Wednesday of every month is officially Insecure Writer’s Support Group day. We post our thoughts on our own blogs. We talk about our doubts and the fears we have conquered. We discuss our struggles and triumphs. We offer a word of encouragement for others who are struggling.

Please visit others in the group and connect with my fellow writers.

Let’s rock the neurotic writing world!

Our Twitter hashtag is #IWSG

And be sure to check out our Facebook group –https://www.facebook.com/groups/IWSG13/

The awesome co-hosts for the May 4 posting of the IWSG are Stephen Tremp, Fundy Blue, MJ Fifield, Loni Townsend, Bish Denham, Susan Gourley, and Stephanie Faris! 

15 thoughts on “Why comment?

  1. I like to comment, and I try to make sure there’s some thought behind it other than “nice post”. As far as if someone else has already said what I would, well, I’ve found that if multiple people have the same opinion, it adds some weight for me, so I won’t deny that to other bloggers. Anyways, fun travels!


    • Never considered the ‘weight of opinion’ angle, but agree. Might rethink my comment strategy bearing that in mind. [Travel report is now re-blogged from wife’s site. BTW she’s the one with family in Boise.]


  2. Like Loni, I like to leave comments on those posts I’ve enjoyed, regardless of how many other comments that person may have received, and I want any comment I leave to have more substance to them than just ‘great post!’ or something like that.

    Travel safe!


  3. Remember, I have clones…
    If I read, I comment. Just because it takes me so long to read! If I can get to the end of the post, I’m leaving a comment, darn it.
    Some slip past me, but I always try to return comments. And I appreciate every one of them, no matter how many I get.


    • Good policy, Alex/clone/whoever. Reaching the end of the post is a positive sign, agreed. And you have learnt the art of meaningful but brief comments – brief and pithy in fact.


  4. When I visit a blog, I always try to leave ‘something’. It will be a comment, if I can contribute something to the discussion (though, like you, I’m unlikely to comment if there are already a lot of comments on the article), and if I can’t see a way to contribute to the conversation, I’ll at least leave a like.

    I always share the posts that I like. Is it a job? Yeah, but it takes less time than one would think (I learned that during the AtoZ last year) and anyway, it’s always posts I like to read and that my readers may also like.
    It’s networking, you know?

    I think exchanging comment, chatting, getting to klnow each other, sharing what we like, is the heart of blogging. That’s my favourite way of networking 🙂


    • Agree that it doesn’t really take much time, especially sharing the posts. I’ve got into the habit of posting those I like – and as you say, readers may also like them.

      And I like that you compare commenting to chatting. In a way that’s very true…even if I say less that way.


  5. I always comment when I read someone’s post, and it’s always more than “nice post” or “great tips”. It might be a sentence long but I address at least one thing. It;s always easier if there’s a question at the end for commenters to answer.


  6. Pingback: A to Z Reflection | Writing Wings

  7. I always try to leave a comment on every post I read, but I have to admit when I’m the 96th person to comment I wonder if my comment has any value. But, then I remember how much I enjoy getting comments and figure the other person will enjoy the 96th comment as much as the 1st. Like Chrys said above I find it helpful if there is a question at the end to use as a comment prompt.

    BTW I see you tweeted my reflections post on your sidebar – thanks! I don’t tweet, so I’m not really sure how it works but I was thrilled to see that you had flagged my post up 🙂


    • Ever since Chrys said that I’ve been adding the 96th comment. Also try posing questions, but not always.

      Usually Tweet a good post in the hope that others get to see it. Still learning about Tweeting though.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.